Charmed: This or That

[Dark Witch.]

Whitelighters, only cause we got to delve into what they are about more. Cause for what it seems like, the darklighters just go aorund killing potential whitelighters and real whitelighters, boring if you ask me lol.

Molecular Inhibition (Freezing) or Molecular Combustion (Explosion)?

[Quadquetra]

Thats a tough choice but i must say Freezing. There are many many moments in a day where i just wanna flick my hands and have everything stop, so I have to choose freezing.

Patty or Grams

[Dark Witch.]

I would need to say Grams, cause she is so kick ass that she just needs to be the one lol. No question for me. lol.

Paige or Piper?

[Quadquetra]

That's easy for me, Piper. She's just all around a great character. She stayed my favorite even in the later years or Charmed. I mean some people don't like her as the eldest sister but i did and i like her as the timid middle sister and i can really relate to how she was in the early seasons of 1-3 and i know what its like being the oldest so Piper all the way.

Elders or The Tribunal

[Nerf]

Elders. The Tribunal was a strange one off. It was kind of a cool idea, but they kept it very basic and didn't take it any further. The Elders developed over the years. Sure, not always for the best, but any development is better than none at all.

Staying on the topic of the Elders: The Elders having only mental powers (S1-5), or the Elders being able to orb, shoot lightning bolts, etc (S6-8)?

[Dark Witch.]

I thought that them only having mental powers was better. I mean, they were meant to be wise, and they were supposed to rarely leave the Heavens, so mental powers made sense. Then with the exception of leo, all Elders had to have offensive and everything. The orbing I didn't mind, but the lightning I did.

The Council or Triad?

[Nerf]

Hmm. Sort of the same thing, but I'll go with the Triad. Cutting it down to just three guys was better, had better robes, and didn't have random snakes around their necks. I also like how they are sort of like the anti-Charmed Ones, in the way that they are stronger together and losing one weakens their power.

Here's a question in relation to that. The Triad of S3 was quite different from the resurrected one of S8, so which do you think was better? The Triad from S3, or the Triad from S8?

[Dark Witch.]

Hmm, that is a good one. I think I like the Triad in Season 8, for though they were different, they were much more character dynamic, making them more than just demons. Also, the fact that they are feared unlike in Season 3 where they are just a force to not be reckoned with. That is my opinion, though I know many others will disagree.

Projection S5 or Projection S8? These two are similar for they were called the same power in the series. The first time we see it is in "Witches In Tights" and then of course on Billie. So which do you like it better?

[Nerf]

Ugh. S5, completely. That one actually seemed to have limits, at least the weakness of having the paper/drawing be destroyed. But with Billie it made it seem like she could do anything with it. I think they realized quite quickly how dumb it was and it made her too powerful, so they didn't use it much, but still. Bah! Hated it. Would have been kind of cool if she could project illusions, but... eh. Whatever.

Which season do you like Prue the best? S1, S2, or S3?

[Dark Witch.]

Oh, that is another toughy! I think I may have to go Season3, only because though she needed a life, Prue was really cool with being superwitch,s he knew what was going on, and how to vanquish things, AH! she was so cool. I miss Prue...haah. Anyways, Season 3 is my answer.

Source S3 or S4?

[Nerf]

S4. The one time we saw him in S3 he was just a little... overly evil. The look with the swords and wings and such. Eh. He just became more interesting in S4 with some really good plans. Became more active. And I liked the simple hooded robe better.

"Enter the Demon" or "12 Angry Zen"? (Two chinese based episodes)

[Dark Witch.]

Hmm, I would have to chose "Enter the Demon" for 2 Angry Zen wasn't as great as the other. This one had action, and also talked about reincarnation and the recycling of life. The only one part I didn't like was how we never saw it again, and when did people ever cross it? That was the only part I didn't like about it.

"Lucky Charmed" or "Nymphs Just Wanna Have Fun"?

[Quiet Desperation]

Hmm, I really like both episodes, but I prefer "Nymphs Just Wanna Have Fun". It was a great, funny episode. I really enjoyed it. I think it's one of my favourite episodes of season 5.

"Run Piper, Run" or "Desperate Housewitches"?

[Nerf]

No contest there. "Run, Piper, Run."

It was one of their rare non-demon episodes and they did it well. I think it was a great idea to have one of their looks accidentally be a real person. And have that person be a wanted criminal? Whoops! ;D And Piper used her freezing power FOUR times! Something basically unheard of in the later seasons. There was also a good amount of the ever awesome martial arts, Paige used her tele-orbing power, and Phoebe had a premonition. Although, that last thing is part of what I don't like about the episode. She seemed to have finally had a premonition that wasn't about her and was about saving an innocent, but... nope! It was all about being there for "the moment." GAH! Phoebe actually really annoyed me in this episode, and she is my favorite, so... yeah. In that first scene where she is on the phone with Paige, then repeats everything twice at the end. Very annoying. And ugh, Alyssa and the guy who played Dex had zero chemistry! Their scenes together were always so boring. *sigh* The saving grace was that Alyssa looked fantastic in her last scene with that red dress.

Leo in S1-5, or Leo in S6-8?

[Dark Witch.]

1-5 without a doubt! I know everyone says Leo shouldnt have becme an Elder at all. I didn't mind that at all. But Leo got too emotional and didnt play it well n the last 3 seasons. So, I would have to go with whitelighter Leo.

Phoebe 1-2 or Phoebe 3-4? (preCole, Cole/Phoebe era)

[Nerf]

I actually liked in S6 where Leo got more of a back bone. And I did like in S7 the avatar arc and how he could really help out with the demon fighting. But it's also where I started to like his character less and less. Maybe it's how he was written, or how Brian acted (really did hate the monkey face). Maybe it's because he was just around way too much. I was so happy in S8 when he left and we got some time without him, so that I was actually happy to see him when he came back.

Anyway. I would have to say Phoebe in S3 & 4. I think she really started to mature in S3 and I loved her relationship with Cole. I thought it was the most interesting relationship on the show and obviously her best. Alyssa and Julian had such great chemistry. And in S4 she matured even more, becoming a great middle sister. These two seasons were a great mix of the earlier and later seasons. Stronger and mature, but still had her wonderful heart when she was always there for her sisters. Before they started to really change her and damage her character.

When Phoebe & Paige switched bodies ("Enter the Demon"), or when Piper & Leo switched powers ("Siren Song")?

[Astral Martin]

Noo!! I literally can't choose! Both episode had it's funny moments and their serious moments..And then more funny moments. But if I had to choose...Siren Song. Because they had to walk a mile in each other's shoes.

With Enter the Demon, Paige and Phoebe were already getting along, if anything they prolly should have had Piper switch w/ Paige, just so they can to see through each other's eyes and see how difficult to be each other...for them...if that makes sense...

All right...Forgot if this was a question but if it was sorry...CO as Valkyries or as Goddesses?