Harrison
Warlock
Shadows Cast: 9
[ss:Shadow Tales - Halloween 2008]
Posts: 476
|
Post by Harrison on Jan 10, 2009 5:00:20 GMT
rate usernames, avatars, & signatures
In this game you must rate the person who wrote the latest and most current post.
You must rate them on their username, avatar, and signature.
Rate using a 1-10 scale and please provide a comment to why you rated the way you did. Note: Please do not be rude and still remain respectful even if you are not a fan of what the person has.
|
|
|
Post by Nerf on Jan 11, 2009 8:24:39 GMT
Username: 8 -- It's not like I could just slam it, since it's your actual name, but I knocked off a couple points since the name reminds me of Harry Kim from Star Trek Voyager and I really didn't like him. Avatar: 9 -- Good picture of Prue, I like the colors used, and it's also a nice little saying under it. Sig: 2 -- There's just not really much there. No banner, or quote or anything. Eh, just a little boring.
|
|
Quiet Desperation
Warlock
Shadows Cast: 2
Free[ss:FFotM August - Family Magic]
Posts: 320
|
Post by Quiet Desperation on Jan 11, 2009 9:57:03 GMT
Username: 9 - Really love it. Is that you're nickname? If so or not, still loving it.
Avatar: 8 - Simple, yet really affective. Love the picture pf Phoebe.
Sig : 9 - Really love your banner. Great textures/brushed and colors. Who's on it, btw?
|
|
Melissa
Future Whitelighter
Shadows Cast: 14
[ss:Shadow Tales: Recast]
Posts: 68
|
Post by Melissa on Jan 11, 2009 18:38:44 GMT
Username: 9 - I've always thought your name was so cool, and even cooler that's it's your real name! Avatar: 7 - I really like it, especially the repeated black and white picture, but the coloring in the other picture doesn't do much for me. Signature: 10 - I love invisible sigs!
|
|
Harrison
Warlock
Shadows Cast: 9
[ss:Shadow Tales - Halloween 2008]
Posts: 476
|
Post by Harrison on Jan 12, 2009 4:46:42 GMT
Username: 7. For one, it isn't capitalized and that bugs me when people don't do that. It's like an OCD thing prolly . Also, I think you should put some word in front of your name or after it. I'm sure with your creativity you could come up with something much cooler. Avatar: 10. It definitely reminds me of your personality! The coloring on it is great too. Signature: 6. I'm not a huge fan of the banner. The text doesn't do much for it but the pic and black and white features are great. Haha, love the lyrics to the song too.
|
|
Astral Martin
Warlock
Shadows Cast: 4
None of your business![ss:Witchlighter - Rose]
Posts: 305
|
Post by Astral Martin on Jan 12, 2009 19:23:01 GMT
username: 8/ I kind of liked it but I never was really a fan of the name. But it reminds me of Potter so yeah.
Avatar: 9/ simple yet very creative. nice pic of prue.
sig: 9/ same as above. I liked how it matches the avatar (its a set, i know) And i love the font and the bage coloring! nice! ;D
|
|
Lexi
Warlock
Shadows Cast: 51
[ss:FFotM July - First Born]
Posts: 203
|
Post by Lexi on Jan 13, 2009 3:54:54 GMT
username: 7 - It has an original ring to it, but its based on your fic and I get really confused when people put their usenames as their fics since they can be changed so often and you begin to wonder who it is and what they're going to be next.
Avatar: 8 - its simple but I like it. It really goes with the banner (yes a set)
Sig: 9 - Again its simple but I like the light spots that you have around the light and then further out, its almost as if you have been or are looking at the light. Also, the writing really looks like the light is behind it, its done really well.
|
|
Harrison
Warlock
Shadows Cast: 9
[ss:Shadow Tales - Halloween 2008]
Posts: 476
|
Post by Harrison on Feb 4, 2009 3:22:38 GMT
Username: 9 - I've always liked the shortened form of Alexandra to be Lexi. It's just a good overall forum name too. It's easy to remember and say around the boards. Avatar: 4 - I have to say, even though it's unique, it's very strange and not that great of an avatar. The text is too simple and the pic of Drew Fuller I am not a fan of. Signature: 3 - I'm sorry again to be bagging on it, but I really just don't like it. The different qualities of the different pics contrast too much and the cutting is pretty choppy and poor on everyones but Wes' and Chad's. You've had that same sig for a while now? Any chance you're thinking about getting a new one? I'm sure a talented member around this site would love to make the same-idea of the banner but nicer.
|
|
|
Post by temporalcombustion on Feb 10, 2009 18:21:41 GMT
Username: 8 - It's a great name and it also reminds me of Potter Avatar: 9 - I really like that avatar, I love that picture you used. Signature: 8 - Again, I love that picture and the background is really cool.
|
|
Harrison
Warlock
Shadows Cast: 9
[ss:Shadow Tales - Halloween 2008]
Posts: 476
|
Post by Harrison on Feb 23, 2009 22:47:36 GMT
Ha, I took your advice, Glenn and changed to Potter. Username: 10 - Very creative and unique. Avatar: 10 - I love that pic and you put amazning effects on it for the shine. Signature: 9 - I had to doc you a point because of the text. It's got to go. The set would be amazing without it. Oh, and the site looks nice too.
|
|
|
Post by temporalcombustion on Feb 24, 2009 12:43:05 GMT
I took your advice Potter and got rid of the text. Username: 10 - Great name Avatar: 10 - I love that pic and the effects are great! Signature: /
|
|
Dark Witch.
Witch
Shadows Cast: 7
id never given much thought to how i would die...[ss:Shadow Tales - Halloween 2008]
Posts: 671
|
Post by Dark Witch. on Feb 24, 2009 15:41:10 GMT
Username: 9 - Very unique. Thought it is a little long, I like how you made it a power, very unique as I said lol.
Avatar/Banner: 8 - I gave it the same because, they are the same pictures. They are a little boring since being the same picture, but I guess that is why they make it a set. lol. Not boring boring, but just not as unique as I thought. lol.
|
|
Harrison
Warlock
Shadows Cast: 9
[ss:Shadow Tales - Halloween 2008]
Posts: 476
|
Post by Harrison on Feb 27, 2009 1:05:04 GMT
Username: 10 - It deserves a 10 just because you've stuck with it so long! LOL, also because it really combines your two passion and because it's not the title of one of your fics. Avatar: 9 - Good text. Great pic. Really goes with your fic. Banner: 100! - Haha, it's just stunning. The text, the twins (who look a ton like Paige there) and the marvelous effects and backround are fantastic. Just brilliant work by Brandon.
|
|
|
Post by temporalcombustion on Feb 27, 2009 1:18:28 GMT
Username: 10 - It's still a great name
Avatar: 10 - I love that avatar!
Banner: 10 - Just like the avatar, I love the banner, Great picture of Andy and Prue in heaven. I love the blue color and that pic of Shannen
|
|
Lexi
Warlock
Shadows Cast: 51
[ss:FFotM July - First Born]
Posts: 203
|
Post by Lexi on Mar 17, 2009 22:19:41 GMT
Username: 6 - I love that your name matches your sig and avatar, but the way it is without the space between the and Woogy just reminds me of computer programming, sorry.
Avatar: 7 - I really like Piper and Phoebe's faces but it just seems a little...I don't know...unoriginal. I can't see much that you've changed to it to make it your own rather than it just being a picture resized and cropped a little.
Banner: 8 - I really do like how you've got the shadow behind the sofa, but it took me a while to realise what the writing actually said. At first I thought the "I" was a "1", I wasn't too sure.
|
|
Dark Witch.
Witch
Shadows Cast: 7
id never given much thought to how i would die...[ss:Shadow Tales - Halloween 2008]
Posts: 671
|
Post by Dark Witch. on Mar 18, 2009 17:55:37 GMT
Username: 7/10, well that is only because it isnt very original. I mean, its your name, but you know what I mean. Avvie: 8/10, it is really simple, but comical with the Mom? question. Siggie: 8/10, the cuts are a little awkward. But, the idea behind it is good. .
|
|
|
Post by temporalcombustion on Mar 28, 2009 1:03:49 GMT
Username: 9/10, I really like it, and it's original
Avatar: 9/10 The avatar looks very cool.
Banner: 9/10 Just like the avatar. It looks very cool. I love the effects, pictures and especially all colors.
|
|
Dark Witch.
Witch
Shadows Cast: 7
id never given much thought to how i would die...[ss:Shadow Tales - Halloween 2008]
Posts: 671
|
Post by Dark Witch. on Apr 5, 2009 18:32:13 GMT
Username: 8/10 Simple, and semi original lol.
Avatar: 8/10 It is okay, the red looks a little weird, but it is okay lol.
Sig: 9/10 awesome sig
|
|