Katy Cassidy or Genieve Cortese?

[Active Engaged]

I prefer Katy, she had a spark whereas Genvieve is kinda boring..

[Astral Martin]

ssssssssssss...ah, that's pretty tough...
The only reason I say Genieve is that I've only seen
about 5 episodes with Katy since I'm just getting into Supernatural with the 4th season. As with Genieve I've seen her in all of her episodes and I like her better...so maybe if I see some episodes from s3 then I can get a better idea of how she acts...

[Lexi]

See I liked the character of Ruby when Katie was playing her. She had a mystery about her where you had no idea which side she was really on. I like Katie Cassidy as an actress too which helped, I'd seen her in Black Xmas before Supernatural. Where as Genieve Cortese I haven't. Also, Katie started off the role of Ruby, so I will always see Ruby as her.

[Harrison]

I definitely have to say Katie from what I've seen of S3 and S4. She fits the personality so much better than Genieve IMO.

So yeah, like Lexi - "I will always see Ruby as her."

[Phoenixlighter]

It's not even funny how much I prefer Katie Cassidy over Genevieve Cortese, but I did take a liking to Genevieve in "I Know What You Did Last Summer" and she did a better-than-usual job in "Heaven and Hell" but she failed to deliver some of the lines that Katie would've nailed. Also, Katie Cassidy isn't the greatest actress either, but she definitely molded that character into what she is and it's been hard seeing Ruby with a lisp, but at least some acting classes look to be present. I just wish that Katie is as easily affordable as Genevieve was so we wouldn't even have to waste precious finger-clicking time on this topic.

[jan0009683]

Katie was better because she played Ruby at first and Katie is a better actress than Genieve.

[mliisza]

Definitely Katie, because Genieve annoyed me... I think Katie made Ruby more mysterious where as Genieve seemed kind of robotic to me.